
We have all done it. Backed into a corner, seeing no way out, we weighed our options and took the low road. We lied. Then we comforted ourselves with a variety of statements to quiet our conscience: “They would not understand.” “It was necessary for the moment.” “I’m not really lying; I’m just not telling the full truth.” Or perhaps we didn’t lie at all. Perhaps we only deceived someone, telling a half-truth instead of a full-blown lie.
But what lies (pun intended) at the heart of a liar? Why do people choose to communicate and act this way, and what is a gospel-centered way to help someone you believe is lying to you? Sinful choices can travel many roads (there are not three reasons people lie and that is it), but some paths are more commonly traveled. In this series, we will look at why someone lies and how to help them.
The Heart of the Lie
When we consider what is at the heart of a person who regularly chooses not to tell the truth, it helps to think of a tree. You can’t have an apple without dirt, and the dirt needs the right mixture. Without the proper soil, fruit cannot grow. In this post, we look at that soil: what must be true of a person before lying can take root. In the next post, we look at the roots, the desires that draw from that soil and produce the fruit.
The Fertile Soil
Four ingredients make up the soil of a person who regularly lies. First, they value the wrong things; they do not value what God values. Second, they lack conviction about what God’s word says on telling the truth. Third, they sincerely believe they can get away with it. Finally, they are not cultivating the heart attitudes God requires.
Valuing the Wrong Things
This is the first and most significant problem we all have, and it is where every heart begins to go astray. We think something is worth more than it is. We ascribe value to what is worthless. The person who lies believes the wrong things are important. We will flesh out what those things are in the next post, but we need to see this step first. They put a high value on the things God values little.
Lacking in Conviction
The next ingredient is a lack of conviction about what God’s word says. The person sees a gray area. They see room for an exception to the rule or, worse, they have abandoned what God’s word says altogether. Yet Scripture is clear: God calls us to tell the truth. The ninth commandment forbids false witness (Ex. 20:16), and Jesus calls the devil “the father of lies” (John 8:44).
Perhaps the person points to the two places in Scripture where people lied and God did not immediately condemn them: the Hebrew midwives who deceived Pharaoh (Ex. 1:15–21) and Rahab, who hid the spies (Josh. 2). But the text does not commend the lie in either case. God dealt well with the midwives because they feared him (Ex. 1:17, 20–21), and Rahab is commended for her faith (Heb. 11:31; James 2:25). The commendation falls on their fear of God and their faith, not on their deception. Over and over, God’s word condemns lying and untruthfulness (Prov. 12:22).
The person who lies has lost this conviction. They have chosen not to believe what God’s word says about lying. They fail to see that Revelation places liars alongside murderers, the sexually immoral, sorcerers, and idolaters (Rev. 21:8; 22:15).
Believing They Can Get Away with It
Within the heart of everyone who lies is the deeply held belief that they will get away with it. (So it is only natural that a liar is also a proud person.) They believe they are skilled enough to mislead the people they are speaking to. This is a subtle pride. We are used to seeing proud people who are boisterous, obnoxious, and easy to spot. But many sins carry a quiet form of pride, and one of its fruits is lying.
Cultivating the Wrong Heart
Finally, a lying heart thrives in soil that is not being cultivated the way God commands. Leave a garden unattended and it grows weeds. Leave it for years and you cannot tell it was ever a garden at all. The person who lies has not cultivated the right desires, and has not trained their mind to think on what is true, right, noble, and excellent (Phil. 4:8). They have not walked the right paths, and so they find themselves committing the sin of lying.
Conclusion
In the next post, we will look at the prevailing desires of the heart in people who choose to lie. Anyone seeking to help a liar must figure out what that person wants more than they want to please Jesus. In the final post, we will look at how to respond to someone you suspect of lying and, if they want help, how to minister to them.
