
This is the last post in our three-part series on lying. We have looked at the soil that leads a person to choose to lie as well as the controlling desires of the heart. In doing so, we see what is happening underneath the action so that we can help someone change. In this post, we look at how to respond to a person you think is lying before they have come clean, and then at what to do when someone seeks help with this sin.
Responding to Someone You Suspect Is Lying
One of the most frequent questions I hear from counselors and church members is what to do with a person they suspect is lying. We often leap from suspicion to certainty and act as if we have hard proof when what we have is circumstantial at best. In this section, we look at what we should do when we don’t know for sure, when the person won’t admit it, or when they claim to be telling the truth and we do not believe them.
Pray from the Start
Begin with prayer. God can do what you cannot. By praying for the person and bringing them before the throne, you are asking the God of heaven to act. You will also develop a heart of love for them. You will see that they are a sinner just like you, and just as much in need of the saving grace of Christ. You will entreat the Holy Spirit to convict them of their sin. Over and over, we fail to pray for those who mistreat us (Luke 6:28).
Ask Lots of Questions
One of the hardest things for us to do is ask questions. We tend to jump to conclusions and assume we know what is going on. We think we have enough data (however we gathered it) and we are ready to conclude, often without asking many, if any, questions of the person. Instead, we rely on third-party information or other unreliable means. If you do not think someone is telling the truth, one of the most important things you can do is ask a lot of questions. There are two reasons.
The first reason is that we should assume there may be a misunderstanding on our part, and that with a little more information we would come to a different conclusion. This is the path of humility, which recognizes that we do not know everything, puts others first, and listens before speaking.
The second reason is that if a person is lying, questions will cause the story to unravel. The liar will struggle to supply details fast enough, and often enough, to keep the story consistent. As the details begin to come apart, they may begin to suspect that you know. It is essential not to accuse anyone at this point. Continue to ask questions. Many will choose to come clean here.
That said, you are not the Jr. Holy Spirit. You are not the fourth member of the Trinity. You are not a detective. Your calling is not to find out the truth but to faithfully do what God has called you to do with the knowledge you have. Using extraordinary means to find out information (snooping, lying yourself, and so on) is not what God wants you to do.
Believe the Best
We are called to believe the best in people (1 Cor. 13:7). That does not mean being duped over and over. It does mean giving the person the benefit of the doubt and first seeing whether we have the story wrong. People often object here and grow concerned that they are being tricked. We can simply entrust ourselves to the righteous judge (1 Pet. 2:23) and remember that every person will give an account to God for all they have done (2 Cor. 5:10).
Remember They Need to Be Loved
Love will do more than anything else we try. A person who is lying to you (and others) is a sinner in need of grace and is often weighed down by fear and shame. They may not come across that way. Beneath the hard and slippery exterior is a person who needs not only your love but the love God offers in Christ. By showing love, and by pointing them to the love God has for those who come to him, you will accomplish what no amount of questions or sleuthing ever will.
Ask Them to Write It Out
Alongside questions, it can help to have a person write out an account of events that do not seem to line up. It lets you see on paper what the person is saying. In conversation, you miss much of what is said because you must process so quickly that it is hard to keep up. A written account lets you go at a slower pace and study it for gaps. A significant gap in time, for example, can sometimes signal that something is missing, though gaps also happen innocently, so ask about them rather than assume.
A written account also gives you both a clear record. If the story changes later, you can gently point back to what was written, and the person will either have to admit the truth or spin another lie. Frame the request as a way to get the facts right for everyone involved, not as a way to build a case.
Confront Them When Facts Seem to Contradict
This is often where people want to start, but it belongs toward the end, and it must be done graciously (Matt. 18:15). When you have contradictory information, lay it out and ask how the person would explain it. Back to the wife and the concert tickets from the previous post: her husband should simply show her the cost of the tickets and ask what happened. Why did they cost more than she said? There could be a reasonable explanation. Before getting upset or angry, he should lay out the facts and ask. Not only might she have a reasonable answer, but she might also come clean after being lovingly and graciously confronted with the facts.
Be Patient with Them
Finally, we must be patient with all people (1 Thess. 5:14). Scripture is clear that we are not to write people off because they sinned against us. That patience looks like the forgiveness Christ calls for when Peter asks how often he must forgive his brother and Christ answers, seventy times seven (Matt. 18:21–22). To act that way, you will need a great deal of patience with your brother or sister in Christ. Remember how patient Christ has been with you. Remember that he is longsuffering with your sin, that he is not giving up on you, and that you should not give up on your brothers and sisters.
Gospel Truths for the Repentant Liar
Now we pivot. Up to this point, we have been dealing with a person we suspect is not telling the truth, but we either can’t tell or they are unwilling to admit it. Now we turn to a repentant person who wants to change and who knows it is wrong to lie.
A note before we begin: several of these points assume the person belongs to Christ. If they do not, the most loving thing you can do is call them to repent and believe the gospel, since no change of habit can substitute for new life in Christ.
Call Them to Worship Something Better
We are all worshipers. God designed us to worship him, but we all went astray. Instead of worshiping the Creator, we worshiped created things (Rom. 1:25). The person who lies is worshiping the wrong thing. Perhaps they want the praise of man more than the praise of God. Perhaps they want the comfort and ease that comes with lying. Whatever it is, you as the counselor must point them to something better. This is where John Piper’s Christian Hedonism is so helpful.
Christian Hedonism holds that God is most glorified in us when we are most satisfied in him. It is beyond our scope to say much more, but when we worship what we were made to worship, we live fuller, happier lives. By directing the liar to worship the right person, they will find the true joy, satisfaction, and peace they were looking for.
Point Them to a True Identity
Often the person who struggles with lying has an identity crisis. How they see themselves is not good, even if they put on a strong show. They may hate themselves, feel inferior, or, at the other extreme, think they are the greatest. Whatever it is, they do not have an identity as a saved, forgiven, loved, redeemed child of God. By pointing them to their identity in Scripture, you help them put off the wrong identity and put on the one Christ has given them. Paul ties this put-off, put-on language directly to lying (Eph. 4:22–25; Col. 3:9–10). When we have the wrong identity, we end up going down all kinds of wrong paths.
Remind Them of the Truth During Temptation
The person who lies often does not keep God’s word at the forefront of their mind. They don’t regularly rehearse and believe all that God has promised in Scripture. Why do they cover something up? Perhaps they are not sure God will take care of them. Why do they deceive a friend? Perhaps they are not convinced of what God’s word says about the consequences of lying. By immersing the liar in God’s word, combing through the promises of God, and correctly applying them to their life and situation, you help them see more and more clearly why they should put off lying and put on telling the truth.
Direct Them to Confession
Finally, encourage the liar to confess when they have lied. Ps. 32:2–5 describes both the wasting away of the one who stays silent and the blessing of the one in whose spirit there is no deceit; see also 1 John 1:7–9 and Prov. 28:13. The person should confess not only to the one they lied to but also to the key people in their life who serve in accountability or mentoring roles. Those people can speak the truth, look for patterns, ask questions, and help in many other ways.
Daily confession to God, perhaps during a morning quiet time, should also be regular. Asking God each morning for help against the temptations he knows are coming, because the person knows their own heart, is a helpful step in growing to be like Christ.
Conclusion
Helping a person out of a habit of lying will be hard, but the Lord will give grace not only to that person but to you as well! Remember, you have your own struggles, and you are no better. Focus on the heart of the person and not just the actions. And pray: not only when all else fails, but from the beginning. Praying for the person from the start is one of the most God-glorifying things you can do.
Much more could be said about helping a person who struggles with lying. What would you add?
